From: David J Bush CSTONE NET> Date: 16 mar 2001 Subject: Art of Shogi: question [ATTACHMENT] This is a multi-part message in MIME format. ------=_NextPart_000_0048_01C0ADF3.B92BFDA0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset="iso-8859-1" Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit Uh, sorry to bother y'all again, but I posted this shortly after I joined this mailing list with my new email, and I may have been the only one who received it. Here it is again, still with attachment. I hope someone finds it worthy of comment. Thanks | In Hosking's "The Art of Shogi," pages 252-253, Sato-Habu, Ryu-O game 1, | Paris 1994 is shown. 1.P2f P8d 2.P2e P8e 3.G7h G3b 4.P2d Px2d 5.Rx2d P'2c | 6.R2f S7b 7.P1f P1d 8.S3h P6d 9.P7f P8f 10.Px8f Rx8f 11.P'8g R8b 12.P4f S6c | 13.S4g S5d 14.S5f P3d 15.K6h B3c 16.Bx3c+ Nx3c 17.S8h S2b 18.G5h P2d | 19.P3f S2c 20.S7g K4b 21.N3g P6e 22.G4g G5b 23.P9f P9d 24.K5h R6b 25.P7e P4d | 26.R2i K3a 27.K4h K2b 28.S7f P6f 29.Px6f Rx6f 30.S(7f)6g R6b 31.N7g P'6f | 32.S7f P7d 33.P'6d Px7e (See the attached .gif diagram.) | | Sato here played 34.S(7f)6e, and Hosking says "again not 34.Sx7e B'6g." | The "again" refers to an earlier variation where the 6th file was not | blocked. But here there is a pawn on 6d, and I don't see the problem with | 34.Sx7e B'6g 35.Sx6g Px6g+ 36.Gx6g. What am I missing, please? What's | white's follow-up? | | Thanks very much for your time! | | David Bush | | ------=_NextPart_000_0048_01C0ADF3.B92BFDA0 Content-Type: application/octet-stream; name="ryuo94-1a.gif" Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64 Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="ryuo94-1a.gif" R0lGODdhgAEuAfcAAAAAAP////QswPAAshQVADm/AHD4AAATAGaIAAAA/wAAvv8A8gAARP8A/74A vvQA8ogAQAIAvuQA8kwAPP8AAL4YAPUfAAwAAAAAAgAAOgAA+AADAADAAAACAAA3AAAEAOIAANUA AMYAAPQ5AFCgAAD/AAC+AADzAAmAAP//AL4pAPXqAACQAAC+GAD2FiVg+AACGABXOAFMWLUAAJkA AosATAMAAMAAABAAAAIAABQAAH4AANgAABQYvjkW8nD4oAP//8C+KwD1cBIAGAAgAAAABAAAzwAY FADiAADVAQDGAwC1AACZAAKLaxYAACwAAAAGAAAYAAA5AAGIABMAAAAJAAH0ACNQAAAADgAAEHQA AAEAAAAYGAAfOE4AWAACAms3TAA3TAQjABggABcAADEAALAAAAXwAAACMv/mzQAY9L4AGPUAHygg AAQAANcAAPUAOrwAlL4AAPUAALgAALQAAAAyAADNAAD0AL4YvvUf8zAAEAQAK0sAb2gCJBgAvh8A 8wAgGP8AAv8AjP/r5AABAEHrACUAAKgAAPUAFqQA+KAAAgIAIBQALX4AM9gAEAAAEwAAOAAA8AEA /i4ACAEABYAAYAE8AgAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAACH5BAAAAAAALAAAAACAAS4B AAj/AAMIHEiwoMGDCBMqXMiwocOHECNKnEixosWLGDNq3Mixo8ePIEOKHEmypMmTKB8CWAkgI8uW F1+uxPjSZU2NMGOytDkTZ8qfQC3mDDB04tCiQmkSRCqRqU6lA52qXGozqNWrDY/GpOpzK0epFXtu BNtUKVmsaH9qTRq1q1e3Y4l2PAuRbta0eNPmFBt2J9ywRPlSlOnTLkO/cV3mXXx1p2GEa98+Ffj4 YGTAcr8mVsy4s9XKBi9jhkpZs1fQC1FbNu25NUrVbWOz5Vx682DCtkf/dc2bNWzZmWeTDj6YK23d v2uz7s18rOC+z41+RSyU+nDoyQPfvN68u/fv4MOL/x9Pvrz58+jTq1/Pvj1ImfDjy59Pv779+/jz 69/Pv7///wD+515KARZo4IEIJqjgggwKOOBJ0enGnXATSihZhcU59yCE2Rl3HIbS5XbhiBROtiFJ EWa4W4ksWtiiih+aeGJq1jkUXYqBrWYUUh0CB2JZIr4YYkE43tjjeDVGZKR9OupHGY/L/ahklCS6 iJ9lR4KHY11MFdllVEdJ9VyWZFIpJJAreonljKGR2SVYNyaU4phmumgnjFLWtaacb7IJZpY5tqlQ nJCJCWWQdw4Z45lTCsrnnmw65hSPSQZK5H06Quqoh3lOhSieVYKqXX2abiipdYcqt1Sfj4bWKqQw lZL5qaKd2mimmpuyJ5ZfhA5a6pODfvkkk8AGJ+uKiaK5qJVwstreqWC6etivllIbZrSFWnrssqIm 22iazVKb3q7YlitntsVeme6rgooWKq3vKlvrXeliWq+plK46Lbqj5josp/pm6y6jes4qb7zfbmfu vwszfB5fu24Z7qiCQUwnlkX1pPC28+6LbLcZwnfpqvkS6f8jeqj6GuylFjtsskqxVlwnyPAS7Olf G8c86ZtbRorbyLC2VClxWQkts8HfcluztwVvOtPQFxPtXYFKwglskcMSq7DUNtuKdNNKH8zV0xMb B+hrOwd8W2r9qlztnKmGnXTHbH99M2Rts6vc2Xpd21fW/qkK9K8cIww23W5zRnW1f/KNVst/F+sv 3vxOXnjX9H68tIoR9sy4z2rvWHTm/tInuOF3I36u3V7TOPqDpjfM5et1UyxfZlHLfTjqreueeuV6 P5ux32sfFruqEQd/OdO/Y+6x7qTKfmLEv3Uu8vODWz7z5tyLzXzvJG8NPOgahu85wNJ/vjzN3rM/ 94XXw+z/55/TTQ4+/RhLq3n73b/vfO3pc9383rO+/u3uf4lTHeX2V7UBEnB7/Iug/75HOgVmqioO 9Mj57ofA1THwgBTEHu9ol0HnNOiEKEyhClfIwv2UcC4FlCAI3TdDAzYvhAJ8IU5iOEEa3tCHHMRh AmWkQyKOUIQdXKDvggjEChqxiMX74A9t2DoAnSyJF7Sg/aDYFB7WEE1JMpKHxIjE0Vhxb2d0Exdp 4sUpgrFGY8qYypKXRcmQsXbWc2J11vhEIXqQNjHLnvo8SEf9KS2QkntZDoe4Rz5GTopMHNJeiJfI 00mukIrk1iSlRxfPqRFfhtlgJY8IwOFoLHS9QiUlr2inukJ2rnSdrB/sfjY+Emoxk6ZE5NuERbLQ ne5ykBul1KjjSVkO6Hyi9CUpGSmhUyYylWOMpYiIGTdLBpOZUXSPJ2GTzFIu84+Nu+SkbKnECq2y nOUqZvnQh6ROcrONkVQWr3T5SvPZi5U0VCfl9IlBdoqnZ91UJhYNeZ1NamucguRnQV3oT4ES1Iji Cw9AqwdPPZrRnlojJ7YKVzFpLhKcEMVnd5z0yCValHN0xKTZ0pYrL8INef1paBf15/84DiWUohDs oSThaFCazvN2w/QNS7M3vC3iMqSW/E5HBdlA1p1UkpVUaWyud0eZJuyn8fmlRh/aSLOZZ6kOtVFF y8g5c6WUXCwLXlJDhpuqijSAb22qV8sDVrh+9JvoFI7Geiq+oYaVoy+to7iO2tVwfjU/hb2lVcG2 12hFlGtRtRqi3LpYhfZxXEUN61abSFZaNTZQc1qZMBf7w7oK1qikFSu+bmpXpg6UsMz6rDdfBtDt SRW2ruVqSYXH2oAGFKSvjaYu4ymX2hpsuHlFbVxnd0z+ZFOxy02dzu4J2dzitn9G89gZqyu6WRL2 t58LbnSZmEx3PlWG/AQvd2c6P2f/dReS59WpDN0o39Fed76q9VMcL0vF+H6xvv8NMH0FnN/pRW+3 eD0tZ2frx+QuGJvvNbByN9vfzuLXvwPOMHEJTGEDZ6eFIA6xiEdMYsQW8cNjZfCDgdtgBVdYxRF2 pFxNamEAaxjDG75xjZkrY/bCd8c6hvGFgVxFMSnxkz2eMXTX+mIIBwtiOR3fJClF5dR2OMmDbTKL V+zgQiG0KyS92M/iR2ZjYrnANBayjXMcXitr95wNK+pnaTneK59Zs0NWM4d3bNkXBRZg1wwvku9s vCgH2cnyHdp9e/jnK1JSUm6+K6Fr2WLdctnFkM7U+hptTb7mCMrrnLRof6znQ2/5rlRHY3L7/hyr kRmUbMgzs6gpfWlLa3mB1BOmHDejLtDKhleOhfXeZD3rCe+51GzOHLRGWU079rRde3EZPQVN7GLj ec04zvbz0Mq43GHopZdZi2nrXOg21VRXKUb0sRO4X9lt2lDEMfKn50Puu0Zb1Oq1dZ7V3bxghrFO qJpuNKcaSGgi1dr5XvS6t4zdVEea3/XaNeDoDOpBqzrJCX84w/e9cWwT+WoOb3c66z1qkv+fON0d X/g+A3Txgpl4a+fca/zWq2RjzTrjJu8yx3HtV4PPJtDKjPmzB4Zg7RQb5y03tc4BDHSaz5DT8aZ3 Fi1u7Wur3MU7x/ozealJeGdyv4GmetXte2utX13fWzd7aYcHVKG/De08HrvVla72ZGPveNTmNZOQ G3VHyTbnWT46ypd+9qOa1ufIeTZTpwzU0nibv4I3tN2R7d9cw33tyhNoZhUuP7lbt+yXn7y6+3wn qKMG8c/1PNKdTvfQx1fRgNdtpeAoeTtPevWDr7u2Kf/x3vNe0mPHfe19D/HdF5/4Ke+851vbes6L PvnPJ3zzNU5rhJf4+tjPvvYTtPy5R1//98iX/vddH37wA7/qwndq+cn/++O3H/q2J3T6Se3++sN/ /c43vlqDr5qNDV/PsGcs8mZI/UdMtwFqXYSAVdN0/LeA4qd/hKdPPFVl5DZ7Dgh+FsglfrV8GyQx /8dIiKFOYzaC2xFKZGGCyOaBaBZ4N2de+Ed9ghV21SRsMod6VueCAOhRJbd/6HeCyPSBwGUxjfdL q2SDRndeAahqSbheS7h6L+Ql2aVpQJhXDPhdqhSFTJZpNPVkbXZvXtaFIqWFiuSEJQQ3RpMysZd/ SFSF6ONK8+ZPqCZx1RWHX8cnZxhydkgxX3du+sVXf+cjucdVbAiIQrNRURgZlgdNfsh34USziLo2 hlP2iJrFh5hFPyHYbIH4XXCmLfizSVrohcs2SJB4hnHmU6TIbKZ4hKI4iS2oNor3eOJVG4ujM2MT banEbePWd2i0eK64MLmDi5vnbksIRbnYdJkIgwRYi64VjGlHUCKXd3EGZ8y4S4SThuRDVJHIfvZH hWmlYgUndVzjbz4njlxnVtmoia5IWV4of2eBhmr4flSISbd4b41lhKpoTcYjh3HljlbFj6WYdMR4 jNboaG4nXFmFSgAJgea3jdWYkDpUg4HDeuNneJs3dEFXkQSXRhPnXLjDch2ZRqlCif8oo3jmuJD3 500lY3QheJEbiYg9x0t55G6cJI0zqXk8I5IPg4PQmGbstieXCBwip4A6aY/UCHfGSEKUJXfbpHlT eEFsRzYDaDuPpY+VQ5RHWW6SuEhJ2YBYuZNLZnNromhuF3ZIWY5VaZaaYpXSiJOrhVHUZJIPCGSw N5bu8pQzp4jg6JV4h5dDuJU9CEtMqX45SDrt9ofDFIwGd3hmqZh1xJjGdns4+G+C6WQd2DgH6XjN FjRo6TRqiT8KZ3mfF3ldeZIMKXvlFZgyOZoRqIM8WFk6yYHtSHq1toe/dXqb2Us1loSxyZr5o5pK KZAOCY9wOZzaSJrGWX2iSX/HSZz/71iazbmcxYmcrTiZ0PmccSmc0cmcyBiaLbh93vmd4BmeZJhB 88eT1bmd6DmQwemc3ndn5fmVwCmRCpmd9Mmd+Baf+NmU9Zme69mayWme15k1/CmfL6ieBIqd9gmZ +qmGGaicAXqeBip2XOmgdaeCFLqfEbqg7Xlm72k4sgl61qmdGRpqsKmhb9WEJtqfD7qiIkp2/wmf XFhPB8qeI3qhIfqY7JiicwiVeEidLIqhKtqibfaXPqpp2aiIOpqfRYqj7qmkKilVmVlpNzqlAyqh RGqjA7eLQZekXLqkCZqjXsopz0iU01ejACqkS/KiCSaIxCOZWGqmMEqiYKmgYbqPNg4Hp2tKpXia WHMKpm8apEA6oxAKqHpKqBc5jCfXpbPYpX8qqD/Ki1d6pj51lmjKqJJaqKvIlv905aQlR6YTWaWW yka9eZ+hSqmByqlxukPdx3yfulxX2aiomqcbimUdSiF7eZsgCqp1aqis2qSl6piYGqux6KgsSKq7 6nSgqauwWqp8+pvMamzCKqXK2k/dV6veopvPOpvTKqqrOqS5uqfSCq7aGqGa2lzZ+q28mq7EeqrV NqGXuq2yKq7ouq5f2qTiea/4mq8q1K3emnXseqzROq4uOp3LCrDn6q/BWq7aFLDzyrAIW6UKy1v5 WKCdpmX+x6Sualw00o5RFoDj6UBLSbHhSJVvp4HxiI4ZW3m8STAhu6ppOrD0CmiFaJlltoIP9TRu uZLm1lo8w7O3clsYS6vuVYz/VDJnKYmsvGm0LZWW0zi0TfuzvvSMJdpSeRmzJ3MtY7qx94O1R+u0 QziyOUuyzBK29cqhTjufuNQyWZuHMoqYWGhWTKtHg6iuZ+ub7lqSIiu2e8m2MCemXnaZYOuzVIu2 bbiJZSu0cZu3Wao+LtmJ5RhuJKmAeDtbc2u1FcuzEYtuies0y9F2XWuJUEqAB7m22Mgvdcu5QcKA QNuvfASRMWW5c1qMkPtrT6ul0ViLGimVDCUrs/hlxlqwRZiXTUuTukizF1uwsNqzBCumGrsoNNhq z7S5bqovcwa3zti8hMixqduNO2igErazzRisxptpUfmFbTi+NBiE8oiWP5mah+AydO41oN9bugkF tQETbva7UWO0ub7Iv1GVv4ybW5n7T0fLidGbujPra53YkmEWlvq7wKxlu4c5OBY5TRgZvpg6v1cb iTrrFp4obB9Ju6Y6hsGGhbSoVRQMlVfLmacIu5jIwUA7wBJFsjI3crbxjZfUbWXplCCXw3fKKu3b iD7phrkBxK7ku/90KjiEATWdm11+aHav+oZPnIzmc491WMVMfMMso8LS+btpI5ZNfI+S23JRzMUH TMJhiTVJZcaVusYtXKxJrLU0ermTm72AO45ue3lzKVYnaGhzKcOVaLfia25Ke6fdRrxbjEggTMYr C60d+5qq54NlikYlSILOlENuSmaWDL3+KVOVeVwo2K3WUxnbMoHgi7SEGUcUCFmIysqnOVnlBcgj GT4CG28Oxm15uG23vI6PtW2tbKa9fH7Wd7Aeh6DwOqxWOswGu8zI+67kyq/WWssOW8xz7MKynJP6 ms3avM0R6bLTXHjHHK50266RmqrOPM7MfM6s+7vq/M2T7MJJes3/h/XI2oubpzzIcjx6STvKjwqx 0OxS+8yDAK2yTgR18upj1QpMqyuzAv2zJKl1OIuSXtfGqirKCh21L/wqY8wiMoh2l4xOrEZ00izP mwrAeDfBxUUs8Ey1XyvJZFcydwiO+EnS5FGrlTtdMzekFy24wBNaupuLB11zzorAN2hUPg0uRV1L Mpo+R93ONN1OJh3QtLbTMLuB9rzBDQ2wT03AUW26Rt2mXQ0r1oLTnMzUYK3V/2wai0rLP01Vau2R hxI7JbjFDOzWaE3Iy2vOT0rNg1q8DoXLew3Oz4zGcTwhbHd3hlnNj2tcBn29jNjXVLeOvorA8OuU 88S9+GzPUaw3gr942Vcdzqkn2WYb1lFLFY290vRb2mHb0qY90f9a0XNV2CNSVxWMmVm9G7RtvcIM lDpdvvGKiurqXdPEwqr4wRot0vCSkqE4lDzX27rt1Biz1Z7xnkbsabLIeMfDMdVtwwztmb8mTio9 09Us3HBhl1Y8NmYN2cwbimyqSk2S3v082LH/7aeAJDBq/Fe+/XP2LVmcyUlfrd5yet6jbTd7bF1N 3SkF3t9rVcB/Fc9p/TWWddoDXUYpNUQS7uAWDUGfjN+9CMoDVlUMPrnineGwTMp+93IA98ptHd4n ri4j7s1NXJtBi84C2rAzjtrUOrXNrNe/jePwKd1a4s6tSuPtjOEwns48jszEHHewyc1O/uRQHsxq quRI3uNCHn+TveNWvuTvnMxf6RrRbONVTuXJKxK/HORL/qEPG9SCTbfnJrXzPOaOLOdoduWCzEYn XdJ07liKq3fdbOe7zacf+xnT/NEUDT2NLM3k/ERA3qzizIQPzeYfnuhiDtvVNo0zfK5ATeR53qLm fB3fMLuAJFXTAbuV3+zpbW7NMHTIh9sZYe49ZvjaiE64km6zjzRug25TY05Gdq3lxQro3WvprB7n Wk7WNzHXe87TRS6nHTLqpG6ppi7aZN69hjzt3IqeuN7oyrfspw3aitLNPm7lUKJe2Z6TaV67vj7n 6R7aZa1km65UqMqRtU7QfV7mhI3Qw67n657U+/7AoB7ugp5zzg7VyX7Gmd3pkQ7smaeiE2XuVd61 sPjoQ4mra+7mW5h6N74Yr+4/1+SptM7Inw3wEh+SGJ/xebHxIHTE/z7h/9jvQn3twf+O5nJOxIeO 8B8v8iXv6CaPFyh/QxUO4B+E6l2+6DFGyLluEj2/YSB+7l5d8Eyu8/f87My8XUrqkTjfsNo+Ugq/ 8lw+5KpO4i6f6ltf85CX11vu9EOP9rZ+t2cf9mnv9mvfg1E+93Sfrw8O9zc/9rIO8zq+7Hhf736f 45Hc9XlP+IDP94Nf9Hp/8G1vnnAeEmfeG7Hct2pf+JWv06L+7hqU9TmPUVx/+cYMzCjumnTWqxe4 zpmOvkLv9Yvv7UMMuVXbxdmk+VpvZ60/74ePLhEFyXAcYXku84F+9RUv/J+uYEqrw3du+nF39EHR shRs+KHP6VVSE2flmqZbU5Wb+mv//ffRT/y7U8mGiLsOMujZD/x/y4TQr9iM6tlF2afRDemPqrqc 35rpC/SBn+St9IqcHC6G3uoAEUDgwIEADB5EmFDhQYINHT6EGFHiRIgGIzK0KDCjQwAUPRb8+LFj SIojSUo0ebKiSpQVTW4syFDjRYsbYRK8qTElS549ff7U6XIkTIQNd/486jNpz6U8m7J8qnKpzaEv bQoNGvNmzplIjXIFGlbpUZlZtcqMejItybUh24oU21Vs1YV1U77kSHSnQrNGgZbVG1ew1Ls5DQMW /Naj4pKJHcedatXsXpyH81JdibRw3sGdS1Y9axe03LCMJ5puCfnxXJcxs5YNMDq2jWi0kh+irvwV ZF/PvV1zpnl7denhf4t7vW27KMfkKJOCxb07t86OsH335gqWN2njqr2z/k4c+GTez59mn6q0+Wzb 132jdy48fHfw9cXb/z1Zduz1rcfPT4g99wac7ivanjtOvfmQw4/BAmfDqS/zDuyvwaCsI/A6+IJj bkEFLWQqwRB1e/Aq7rZ7MD8CMd3M8D3z4usQRKdEnNHDEVPcaijpUiSxxwG1a9GzDf3zy8YaZYSK xiR5PMxEH/9T0cUgp0SPwhjvw5K+LB3UcsjK8LqMtgo7Y3FK97yE8sQPt1xTSze5hBNCDp8srUwz f4xOPiSlUpJPI5fcU6087yT0tEGLDJStPtVaVNE/CSs00sGA9DNRtxq99FFGNWXrUEk/Ze9AUUcl tVRTT0U1VVVXZbVVVykFNVbnXqW1VltvxTVXXV+VtVdffwU2WGGHJbZYY49FNllll2W2WWefhTZa aaeltlprr8U2254CAgA7 ------=_NextPart_000_0048_01C0ADF3.B92BFDA0--