From: David J Bush CSTONE NET> Date: 8 mar 2001 Subject: Art of Shogi: question [ATTACHMENT] This is a multi-part message in MIME format. ------=_NextPart_000_0020_01C0A816.DF57E440 Content-Type: text/plain; charset="iso-8859-1" Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit In Hosking's "The Art of Shogi," pages 252-253, Sato-Habu, Ryu-O game 1, Paris 1994 is shown. 1.P2f P8d 2.P2e P8e 3.G7h G3b 4.P2d Px2d 5.Rx2d P'2c 6.R2f S7b 7.P1f P1d 8.S3h P6d 9.P7f P8f 10.Px8f Rx8f 11.P'8g R8b 12.P4f S6c 13.S4g S5d 14.S5f P3d 15.K6h B3c 16.Bx3c+ Nx3c 17.S8h S2b 18.G5h P2d 19.P3f S2c 20.S7g K4b 21.N3g P6e 22.G4g G5b 23.P9f P9d 24.K5h R6b 25.P7e P4d 26.R2i K3a 27.K4h K2b 28.S7f P6f 29.Px6f Rx6f 30.S(7f)6g R6b 31.N7g P'6f 32.S7f P7d 33.P'6d Px7e (See the attached .gif diagram.) Sato here played 34.S(7f)6e, and Hosking says "again not 34.Sx7e B'6g." The "again" refers to an earlier variation where the 6th file was not blocked. But here there is a pawn on 6d, and I don't see the problem with 34.Sx7e B'6g 35.Sx6g Px6g+ 36.Gx6g. What am I missing, please? What's white's follow-up? Thanks very much for your time! David Bush ------=_NextPart_000_0020_01C0A816.DF57E440 Content-Type: application/octet-stream; name="ryuo94-1a.gif" Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64 Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="ryuo94-1a.gif" R0lGODdhgAEuAfcAAAAAAP////QswPAAshQVADm/AHD4AAATAGaIAAAA/wAAvv8A8gAARP8A/74A vvQA8ogAQAIAvuQA8kwAPP8AAL4YAPUfAAwAAAAAAgAAOgAA+AADAADAAAACAAA3AAAEAOIAANUA AMYAAPQ5AFCgAAD/AAC+AADzAAmAAP//AL4pAPXqAACQAAC+GAD2FiVg+AACGABXOAFMWLUAAJkA AosATAMAAMAAABAAAAIAABQAAH4AANgAABQYvjkW8nD4oAP//8C+KwD1cBIAGAAgAAAABAAAzwAY FADiAADVAQDGAwC1AACZAAKLaxYAACwAAAAGAAAYAAA5AAGIABMAAAAJAAH0ACNQAAAADgAAEHQA AAEAAAAYGAAfOE4AWAACAms3TAA3TAQjABggABcAADEAALAAAAXwAAACMv/mzQAY9L4AGPUAHygg AAQAANcAAPUAOrwAlL4AAPUAALgAALQAAAAyAADNAAD0AL4YvvUf8zAAEAQAK0sAb2gCJBgAvh8A 8wAgGP8AAv8AjP/r5AABAEHrACUAAKgAAPUAFqQA+KAAAgIAIBQALX4AM9gAEAAAEwAAOAAA8AEA /i4ACAEABYAAYAE8AgAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAACH5BAAAAAAALAAAAACAAS4B AAj/AAMIHEiwoMGDCBMqXMiwocOHECNKnEixosWLGDNq3Mixo8ePIEOKHEmypMmTKB8CWAkgI8uW F1+uxPjSZU2NMGOytDkTZ8qfQC3mDDB04tCiQmkSRCqRqU6lA52qXGozqNWrDY/GpOpzK0epFXtu BNtUKVmsaH9qTRq1q1e3Y4l2PAuRbta0eNPmFBt2J9ywRPlSlOnTLkO/cV3mXXx1p2GEa98+Ffj4 YGTAcr8mVsy4s9XKBi9jhkpZs1fQC1FbNu25NUrVbWOz5Vx682DCtkf/dc2bNWzZmWeTDj6YK23d v2uz7s18rOC+z41+RSyU+nDoyQPfvN68u/fv4MOL/x9Pvrz58+jTq1/Pvj1ImfDjy59Pv779+/jz 69/Pv7///wD+515KARZo4IEIJqjgggwKOOBJ0enGnXATSihZhcU59yCE2Rl3HIbS5XbhiBROtiFJ EWa4W4ksWtiiih+aeGJq1jkUXYqBrWYUUh0CB2JZIr4YYkE43tjjeDVGZKR9OupHGY/L/ahklCS6 iJ9lR4KHY11MFdllVEdJ9VyWZFIpJJAreonljKGR2SVYNyaU4phmumgnjFLWtaacb7IJZpY5tqlQ nJCJCWWQdw4Z45lTCsrnnmw65hSPSQZK5H06Quqoh3lOhSieVYKqXX2abiipdYcqt1Sfj4bWKqQw lZL5qaKd2mimmpuyJ5ZfhA5a6pODfvkkk8AGJ+uKiaK5qJVwstreqWC6etivllIbZrSFWnrssqIm 22iazVKb3q7YlitntsVeme6rgooWKq3vKlvrXeliWq+plK46Lbqj5josp/pm6y6jes4qb7zfbmfu vwszfB5fu24Z7qiCQUwnlkX1pPC28+6LbLcZwnfpqvkS6f8jeqj6GuylFjtsskqxVlwnyPAS7Olf G8c86ZtbRorbyLC2VClxWQkts8HfcluztwVvOtPQFxPtXYFKwglskcMSq7DUNtuKdNNKH8zV0xMb B+hrOwd8W2r9qlztnKmGnXTHbH99M2Rts6vc2Xpd21fW/qkK9K8cIww23W5zRnW1f/KNVst/F+sv 3vxOXnjX9H68tIoR9sy4z2rvWHTm/tInuOF3I36u3V7TOPqDpjfM5et1UyxfZlHLfTjqreueeuV6 P5ux32sfFruqEQd/OdO/Y+6x7qTKfmLEv3Uu8vODWz7z5tyLzXzvJG8NPOgahu85wNJ/vjzN3rM/ 94XXw+z/55/TTQ4+/RhLq3n73b/vfO3pc9383rO+/u3uf4lTHeX2V7UBEnB7/Iug/75HOgVmqioO 9Mj57ofA1THwgBTEHu9ol0HnNOiEKEyhClfIwv2UcC4FlCAI3TdDAzYvhAJ8IU5iOEEa3tCHHMRh AmWkQyKOUIQdXKDvggjEChqxiMX74A9t2DoAnSyJF7Sg/aDYFB7WEE1JMpKHxIjE0Vhxb2d0Exdp 4sUpgrFGY8qYypKXRcmQsXbWc2J11vhEIXqQNjHLnvo8SEf9KS2QkntZDoe4Rz5GTopMHNJeiJfI 00mukIrk1iSlRxfPqRFfhtlgJY8IwOFoLHS9QiUlr2inukJ2rnSdrB/sfjY+Emoxk6ZE5NuERbLQ ne5ykBul1KjjSVkO6Hyi9CUpGSmhUyYylWOMpYiIGTdLBpOZUXSPJ2GTzFIu84+Nu+SkbKnECq2y nOUqZvnQh6ROcrONkVQWr3T5SvPZi5U0VCfl9IlBdoqnZ91UJhYNeZ1NamucguRnQV3oT4ES1Iji Cw9AqwdPPZrRnlojJ7YKVzFpLhKcEMVnd5z0yCValHN0xKTZ0pYrL8INef1paBf15/84DiWUohDs oSThaFCazvN2w/QNS7M3vC3iMqSW/E5HBdlA1p1UkpVUaWyud0eZJuyn8fmlRh/aSLOZZ6kOtVFF y8g5c6WUXCwLXlJDhpuqijSAb22qV8sDVrh+9JvoFI7Geiq+oYaVoy+to7iO2tVwfjU/hb2lVcG2 12hFlGtRtRqi3LpYhfZxXEUN61abSFZaNTZQc1qZMBf7w7oK1qikFSu+bmpXpg6UsMz6rDdfBtDt SRW2ruVqSYXH2oAGFKSvjaYu4ymX2hpsuHlFbVxnd0z+ZFOxy02dzu4J2dzitn9G89gZqyu6WRL2 t58LbnSZmEx3PlWG/AQvd2c6P2f/dReS59WpDN0o39Fed76q9VMcL0vF+H6xvv8NMH0FnN/pRW+3 eD0tZ2frx+QuGJvvNbByN9vfzuLXvwPOMHEJTGEDZ6eFIA6xiEdMYsQW8cNjZfCDgdtgBVdYxRF2 pFxNamEAaxjDG75xjZkrY/bCd8c6hvGFgVxFMSnxkz2eMXTX+mIIBwtiOR3fJClF5dR2OMmDbTKL V+zgQiG0KyS92M/iR2ZjYrnANBayjXMcXitr95wNK+pnaTneK59Zs0NWM4d3bNkXBRZg1wwvku9s vCgH2cnyHdp9e/jnK1JSUm6+K6Fr2WLdctnFkM7U+hptTb7mCMrrnLRof6znQ2/5rlRHY3L7/hyr kRmUbMgzs6gpfWlLa3mB1BOmHDejLtDKhleOhfXeZD3rCe+51GzOHLRGWU079rRde3EZPQVN7GLj ec04zvbz0Mq43GHopZdZi2nrXOg21VRXKUb0sRO4X9lt2lDEMfKn50Puu0Zb1Oq1dZ7V3bxghrFO qJpuNKcaSGgi1dr5XvS6t4zdVEea3/XaNeDoDOpBqzrJCX84w/e9cWwT+WoOb3c66z1qkv+fON0d X/g+A3Txgpl4a+fca/zWq2RjzTrjJu8yx3HtV4PPJtDKjPmzB4Zg7RQb5y03tc4BDHSaz5DT8aZ3 Fi1u7Wur3MU7x/ozealJeGdyv4GmetXte2utX13fWzd7aYcHVKG/De08HrvVla72ZGPveNTmNZOQ G3VHyTbnWT46ypd+9qOa1ufIeTZTpwzU0nibv4I3tN2R7d9cw33tyhNoZhUuP7lbt+yXn7y6+3wn qKMG8c/1PNKdTvfQx1fRgNdtpeAoeTtPevWDr7u2Kf/x3vNe0mPHfe19D/HdF5/4Ke+851vbes6L PvnPJ3zzNU5rhJf4+tjPvvYTtPy5R1//98iX/vddH37wA7/qwndq+cn/++O3H/q2J3T6Se3++sN/ /c43vlqDr5qNDV/PsGcs8mZI/UdMtwFqXYSAVdN0/LeA4qd/hKdPPFVl5DZ7Dgh+FsglfrV8GyQx /8dIiKFOYzaC2xFKZGGCyOaBaBZ4N2de+Ed9ghV21SRsMod6VueCAOhRJbd/6HeCyPSBwGUxjfdL q2SDRndeAahqSbheS7h6L+Ql2aVpQJhXDPhdqhSFTJZpNPVkbXZvXtaFIqWFiuSEJQQ3RpMysZd/ SFSF6ONK8+ZPqCZx1RWHX8cnZxhydkgxX3du+sVXf+cjucdVbAiIQrNRURgZlgdNfsh34USziLo2 hlP2iJrFh5hFPyHYbIH4XXCmLfizSVrohcs2SJB4hnHmU6TIbKZ4hKI4iS2oNor3eOJVG4ujM2MT banEbePWd2i0eK64MLmDi5vnbksIRbnYdJkIgwRYi64VjGlHUCKXd3EGZ8y4S4SThuRDVJHIfvZH hWmlYgUndVzjbz4njlxnVtmoia5IWV4of2eBhmr4flSISbd4b41lhKpoTcYjh3HljlbFj6WYdMR4 jNboaG4nXFmFSgAJgea3jdWYkDpUg4HDeuNneJs3dEFXkQSXRhPnXLjDch2ZRqlCif8oo3jmuJD3 500lY3QheJEbiYg9x0t55G6cJI0zqXk8I5IPg4PQmGbstieXCBwip4A6aY/UCHfGSEKUJXfbpHlT eEFsRzYDaDuPpY+VQ5RHWW6SuEhJ2YBYuZNLZnNromhuF3ZIWY5VaZaaYpXSiJOrhVHUZJIPCGSw N5bu8pQzp4jg6JV4h5dDuJU9CEtMqX45SDrt9ofDFIwGd3hmqZh1xJjGdns4+G+C6WQd2DgH6XjN FjRo6TRqiT8KZ3mfF3ldeZIMKXvlFZgyOZoRqIM8WFk6yYHtSHq1toe/dXqb2Us1loSxyZr5o5pK KZAOCY9wOZzaSJrGWX2iSX/HSZz/71iazbmcxYmcrTiZ0PmccSmc0cmcyBiaLbh93vmd4BmeZJhB 88eT1bmd6DmQwemc3ndn5fmVwCmRCpmd9Mmd+Baf+NmU9Zme69mayWme15k1/CmfL6ieBIqd9gmZ +qmGGaicAXqeBip2XOmgdaeCFLqfEbqg7Xlm72k4sgl61qmdGRpqsKmhb9WEJtqfD7qiIkp2/wmf XFhPB8qeI3qhIfqY7JiicwiVeEidLIqhKtqibfaXPqpp2aiIOpqfRYqj7qmkKilVmVlpNzqlAyqh RGqjA7eLQZekXLqkCZqjXsopz0iU01ejACqkS/KiCSaIxCOZWGqmMEqiYKmgYbqPNg4Hp2tKpXia WHMKpm8apEA6oxAKqHpKqBc5jCfXpbPYpX8qqD/Ki1d6pj51lmjKqJJaqKvIlv905aQlR6YTWaWW yka9eZ+hSqmByqlxukPdx3yfulxX2aiomqcbimUdSiF7eZsgCqp1aqis2qSl6piYGqux6KgsSKq7 6nSgqauwWqp8+pvMamzCKqXK2k/dV6veopvPOpvTKqqrOqS5uqfSCq7aGqGa2lzZ+q28mq7EeqrV NqGXuq2yKq7ouq5f2qTiea/4mq8q1K3emnXseqzROq4uOp3LCrDn6q/BWq7aFLDzyrAIW6UKy1v5 WKCdpmX+x6Sualw00o5RFoDj6UBLSbHhSJVvp4HxiI4ZW3m8STAhu6ppOrD0CmiFaJlltoIP9TRu uZLm1lo8w7O3clsYS6vuVYz/VDJnKYmsvGm0LZWW0zi0TfuzvvSMJdpSeRmzJ3MtY7qx94O1R+u0 QziyOUuyzBK29cqhTjufuNQyWZuHMoqYWGhWTKtHg6iuZ+ub7lqSIiu2e8m2MCemXnaZYOuzVIu2 bbiJZSu0cZu3Wao+LtmJ5RhuJKmAeDtbc2u1FcuzEYtuies0y9F2XWuJUEqAB7m22Mgvdcu5QcKA QNuvfASRMWW5c1qMkPtrT6ul0ViLGimVDCUrs/hlxlqwRZiXTUuTukizF1uwsNqzBCumGrsoNNhq z7S5bqovcwa3zti8hMixqduNO2igErazzRisxptpUfmFbTi+NBiE8oiWP5mah+AydO41oN9bugkF tQETbva7UWO0ub7Iv1GVv4ybW5n7T0fLidGbujPra53YkmEWlvq7wKxlu4c5OBY5TRgZvpg6v1cb iTrrFp4obB9Ju6Y6hsGGhbSoVRQMlVfLmacIu5jIwUA7wBJFsjI3crbxjZfUbWXplCCXw3fKKu3b iD7phrkBxK7ku/90KjiEATWdm11+aHav+oZPnIzmc491WMVMfMMso8LS+btpI5ZNfI+S23JRzMUH TMJhiTVJZcaVusYtXKxJrLU0ermTm72AO45ue3lzKVYnaGhzKcOVaLfia25Ke6fdRrxbjEggTMYr C60d+5qq54NlikYlSILOlENuSmaWDL3+KVOVeVwo2K3WUxnbMoHgi7SEGUcUCFmIysqnOVnlBcgj GT4CG28Oxm15uG23vI6PtW2tbKa9fH7Wd7Aeh6DwOqxWOswGu8zI+67kyq/WWssOW8xz7MKynJP6 ms3avM0R6bLTXHjHHK50266RmqrOPM7MfM6s+7vq/M2T7MJJes3/h/XI2oubpzzIcjx6STvKjwqx 0OxS+8yDAK2yTgR18upj1QpMqyuzAv2zJKl1OIuSXtfGqirKCh21L/wqY8wiMoh2l4xOrEZ00izP mwrAeDfBxUUs8Ey1XyvJZFcydwiO+EnS5FGrlTtdMzekFy24wBNaupuLB11zzorAN2hUPg0uRV1L Mpo+R93ONN1OJh3QtLbTMLuB9rzBDQ2wT03AUW26Rt2mXQ0r1oLTnMzUYK3V/2wai0rLP01Vau2R hxI7JbjFDOzWaE3Iy2vOT0rNg1q8DoXLew3Oz4zGcTwhbHd3hlnNj2tcBn29jNjXVLeOvorA8OuU 88S9+GzPUaw3gr942Vcdzqkn2WYb1lFLFY290vRb2mHb0qY90f9a0XNV2CNSVxWMmVm9G7RtvcIM lDpdvvGKiurqXdPEwqr4wRot0vCSkqE4lDzX27rt1Biz1Z7xnkbsabLIeMfDMdVtwwztmb8mTio9 09Us3HBhl1Y8NmYN2cwbimyqSk2S3v082LH/7aeAJDBq/Fe+/XP2LVmcyUlfrd5yet6jbTd7bF1N 3SkF3t9rVcB/Fc9p/TWWddoDXUYpNUQS7uAWDUGfjN+9CMoDVlUMPrnineGwTMp+93IA98ptHd4n ri4j7s1NXJtBi84C2rAzjtrUOrXNrNe/jePwKd1a4s6tSuPtjOEwns48jszEHHewyc1O/uRQHsxq quRI3uNCHn+TveNWvuTvnMxf6RrRbONVTuXJKxK/HORL/qEPG9SCTbfnJrXzPOaOLOdoduWCzEYn XdJ07liKq3fdbOe7zacf+xnT/NEUDT2NLM3k/ERA3qzizIQPzeYfnuhiDtvVNo0zfK5ATeR53qLm fB3fMLuAJFXTAbuV3+zpbW7NMHTIh9sZYe49ZvjaiE64km6zjzRug25TY05Gdq3lxQro3WvprB7n Wk7WNzHXe87TRS6nHTLqpG6ppi7aZN69hjzt3IqeuN7oyrfspw3aitLNPm7lUKJe2Z6TaV67vj7n 6R7aZa1km65UqMqRtU7QfV7mhI3Qw67n657U+/7AoB7ugp5zzg7VyX7Gmd3pkQ7smaeiE2XuVd61 sPjoQ4mra+7mW5h6N74Yr+4/1+SptM7Inw3wEh+SGJ/xebHxIHTE/z7h/9jvQn3twf+O5nJOxIeO 8B8v8iXv6CaPFyh/QxUO4B+E6l2+6DFGyLluEj2/YSB+7l5d8Eyu8/f87My8XUrqkTjfsNo+Ugq/ 8lw+5KpO4i6f6ltf85CX11vu9EOP9rZ+t2cf9mnv9mvfg1E+93Sfrw8O9zc/9rIO8zq+7Hhf736f 45Hc9XlP+IDP94Nf9Hp/8G1vnnAeEmfeG7Hct2pf+JWv06L+7hqU9TmPUVx/+cYMzCjumnTWqxe4 zpmOvkLv9Yvv7UMMuVXbxdmk+VpvZ60/74ePLhEFyXAcYXku84F+9RUv/J+uYEqrw3du+nF39EHR shRs+KHP6VVSE2flmqZbU5Wb+mv//ffRT/y7U8mGiLsOMujZD/x/y4TQr9iM6tlF2afRDemPqrqc 35rpC/SBn+St9IqcHC6G3uoAEUDgwIEADB5EmFDhQYINHT6EGFHiRIgGIzK0KDCjQwAUPRb8+LFj SIojSUo0ebKiSpQVTW4syFDjRYsbYRK8qTElS549ff7U6XIkTIQNd/486jNpz6U8m7J8qnKpzaEv bQoNGvNmzplIjXIFGlbpUZlZtcqMejItybUh24oU21Vs1YV1U77kSHSnQrNGgZbVG1ew1Ls5DQMW /Naj4pKJHcedatXsXpyH81JdibRw3sGdS1Y9axe03LCMJ5puCfnxXJcxs5YNMDq2jWi0kh+irvwV ZF/PvV1zpnl7denhf4t7vW27KMfkKJOCxb07t86OsH335gqWN2njqr2z/k4c+GTez59mn6q0+Wzb 132jdy48fHfw9cXb/z1Zduz1rcfPT4g99wac7ivanjtOvfmQw4/BAmfDqS/zDuyvwaCsI/A6+IJj bkEFLWQqwRB1e/Aq7rZ7MD8CMd3M8D3z4usQRKdEnNHDEVPcaijpUiSxxwG1a9GzDf3zy8YaZYSK xiR5PMxEH/9T0cUgp0SPwhjvw5K+LB3UcsjK8LqMtgo7Y3FK97yE8sQPt1xTSze5hBNCDp8srUwz f4xOPiSlUpJPI5fcU6087yT0tEGLDJStPtVaVNE/CSs00sGA9DNRtxq99FFGNWXrUEk/Ze9AUUcl tVRTT0U1VVVXZbVVVykFNVbnXqW1VltvxTVXXV+VtVdffwU2WGGHJbZYY49FNllll2W2WWefhTZa aaeltlprr8U2254CAgA7 ------=_NextPart_000_0020_01C0A816.DF57E440--