From: Nick Bardsley <nbardsley <at> ICC <dot> CO <dot> UK>
Date: 9 feb 2000
Subject: CHU: Problem A15

I'll just reply to this one, because I don't think too much traffic of =
this nature is strictly necessary.

My comment is that Colin's point about the published solution being =
wrong due to the Phoenix's ineligibilty to promote is not quite right =
(as far as I can see). The solution is wrong inasmuch as the Ph's =
promotion is a typo. That is, '+' should be '=3D' for the Ph's second =
move. Whether the Ph is a Ph or has promoted does not affect the need =
for the King to take it (again, as far as I can see).

So the thrust of the published solution seems to be right.

Nick